Your Guide to the Newborn Witching Hour

If you have noticed your baby becomes a completely different person every evening, almost like clockwork, you are not alone. Welcome to the newborn witching hour. It’s a tricky phase where an otherwise content baby gets incredibly fussy for a few hours, usually right when you are feeling most exhausted.

Here is why. This intense crying often kicks in around 2-3 weeks of age, seems to hit its peak at about 6 weeks, and thankfully, tends to fade away by the time your little one is 3-4 months old.

What Is the Newborn Witching Hour, Really?

That daily period of inconsolable fussiness is a completely normal, albeit draining, part of newborn development. Think of it as your baby’s way of unwinding after a long day. They are taking in a whole new world of sights, sounds, and sensations. By evening, their little nervous systems are just overloaded.

This is an incredibly common experience for new parents across Australia. It’s a temporary stage and definitely not a reflection of your parenting. Just knowing there’s a timeline can bring so much reassurance during those long evenings. If you are in the thick of it, exploring some expert tips on managing this phase can help you feel more prepared.

The Typical Timeline

While every baby has their own rhythm, the witching hour tends to follow a surprisingly predictable pattern.

• Starts around 2-3 weeks: This is when you might first notice a regular pattern of fussiness building in the late afternoon or early evening.
• Peaks at 6 weeks: For many families, this is when the crying can feel the most intense and last the longest. Hang in there.
• Fades by 3-4 months: As your baby’s nervous system matures, you will notice these fussy periods gradually get shorter and eventually disappear.
• The most important thing to remember is that the witching hour is a temporary developmental stage. It's driven by your baby's immature nervous system adjusting to life outside the womb, not by anything you are doing wrong.

Let's break it down a bit more. That evening crying is often just a baby’s way of releasing all the pent-up stimulation from the day. Their tiny bodies and brains are working overtime to grow and learn, and by sundown, they can become completely overwhelmed. This is why they cry, and it often seems like nothing can fix it. Realising this helps shift your mindset from frustration to empathy.

Understanding Why the Witching Hour Happens

That sudden shift from a peaceful, sleeping baby to one who is completely inconsolable can feel baffling. But the newborn witching hour is not random. It is driven by real biological factors. It often helps to see this fussy period not as a problem you need to solve, but as a normal response to your baby’s incredible, rapid development.

Here is why it happens. A newborn's nervous system is brand new and still figuring out how to manage everything. After a full day of soaking in new sights, sounds, and sensations, they can become completely overwhelmed. Unlike adults who can unwind with a book or a chat, a baby’s only release valve for all that built-up stimulation is often a long, hard cry.

The Main Culprits Behind Evening Fussiness

Several key factors often combine to create the perfect storm for evening fussiness. Understanding what is going on under the surface can help you approach this tricky time with a little more empathy and patience.

Let's break it down:

• Immature Circadian Rhythm: Your baby's internal body clock, the one that regulates sleep and wake cycles, is not fully developed yet. They do not produce their own melatonin for months, which means they struggle to tell day from night. This often leads to them becoming overtired just as your own day is winding down.

• Overstimulation Overload: Think about everything your baby experiences in a day. Every new face, every different sound, and each gentle touch is a massive amount of information for their developing brain to process. By the evening, their system is simply at full capacity.

• The Need to Cluster Feed: Many babies, particularly those who are breastfed, will want to feed almost constantly in the evenings. This cluster feeding is their clever, natural way of stocking up on calories for the night ahead and helping to stimulate mum's milk supply for the next day.

Australian research confirms this is a very common experience for new parents. One study found the duration of infant crying peaks at around six weeks of age before gradually reducing. (Crying babies, Pregnancy, Birth and Baby, October 2022).

Digestive Discomfort and Growth Spurts

A newborn's tummy is also on a steep learning curve. Their digestive system is still maturing, which can lead to uncomfortable gas or wind, especially after a long day of feeding. Gentle exercises can sometimes bring relief. You can learn more about this in our guide to the benefits of tummy time for babies.

Remember, the witching hour is a sign of your baby's development, not a reflection of your parenting. They are working so hard to adjust to life outside the womb, and this evening fussiness is a temporary part of that incredible journey.

Finally, babies grow at an astonishing rate. These intense periods of growth, known as growth spurts, require huge amounts of energy and can make your baby extra hungry and fussy. These spurts often pop up right around the same time as the peak witching hour weeks, adding another layer to the evening challenges.

How to Recognise the Witching Hour Signs

Figuring out whether your baby is just having a fussy moment or if you are heading into the witching hour can feel like a guessing game. But once you start noticing the patterns, you can get ahead of it and respond before things really ramp up. This is not just random crying. It is a predictable set of behaviours that tells you your baby is completely overwhelmed.

The biggest giveaway is crying that nothing seems to fix. You have fed them, changed their nappy, given them a cuddle, yet the crying just keeps going, often getting louder and more intense. It’s a distinct, inconsolable sound that’s very different from their usual "I am hungry" or "I am sleepy" cries.

Let's break down what to look for. Spotting these signs early means you can shift from simply reacting to the chaos to putting a calming plan in place before the fussiness really takes hold.

Key Behaviours to Watch For

Beyond that specific cry, a few other things can signal the witching hour is kicking off. They often show up together, painting a clear picture of an overstimulated and overtired baby who’s struggling with some very big feelings.

You might notice these physical and feeding cues:

• Frantic Feeding: Your baby might seem starving, latching onto the breast or bottle only to pull away, cry, and then try again just moments later. This on-and-off feeding shows they are looking for comfort but are just too worked up to settle and feed properly.
• Physical Signs of Discomfort: Look for an arched back, clenched fists, and stiff little arms and legs. These are classic signs that your baby is overtired and their nervous system is completely overloaded.
• Resisting Soothing: All the usual tricks that calm your baby down during the day suddenly do not work. They might even seem to fight against you as you try to soothe them, which can be incredibly tough.

The core difference is predictability and intensity. While typical fussiness is often resolved with a feed or a change, the witching hour is a recurring, daily event where standard soothing methods fall short. It’s the pattern that tells the story.

To help you quickly figure out what is going on, we have put together a simple comparison.

Witching Hour Signs vs Typical Fussiness

This quick reference guide can help you distinguish between a standard fussy period and the onset of the witching hour.

Behaviour	Typical Fussiness	Witching Hour Sign
Crying	Can be soothed by feeding, changing, or cuddling.	Is often intense, inconsolable, and resists usual calming methods.
Timing	Can happen at any time of day for a clear reason.	Occurs predictably every day, usually in the late afternoon or evening.
Feeding	Baby feeds calmly and settles afterwards.	Baby may cluster feed frantically, latching and pulling off repeatedly.
Body Language	Generally relaxed once the need is met.	Often includes an arched back, clenched fists, and general stiffness.

Next steps? Let's move on to the tried-and-true soothing strategies that can actually bring some relief during these challenging evenings.

Proven Soothing Strategies That Actually Work

When you are in the thick of the newborn witching hour, it can feel like nothing on earth will calm your baby. The trick is to have a little toolkit of strategies ready to go, all focused on recreating that safe, comforting feeling of the womb. It helps you stay calm and respond with confidence when the fussiness kicks in.

Let's break it down. Most of the best soothing methods work by engaging your baby’s senses in a gentle, familiar way. Rhythmic movement, calming sounds, and secure pressure are your best friends because they mimic the sensations your little one was used to before birth.

Create a Womb-Like Environment

Your baby just spent nine months in a warm, dark, noisy, and snug space where they were constantly moving. Bringing those elements back can be incredibly calming for their tiny, overstimulated nervous system. Think less stimulation, more security.

A great first step is to simply dial down the sensory input. Evenings are often busy. Older kids are coming home, dinner is being made, and bright lights are on. It’s a lot for a newborn.

• Dim the lights: Lowering the lights is a powerful signal that the day is winding down. Switch off bright overheads and use a soft, warm lamp instead.
• Reduce noise: Turn off the TV and lower the volume on any music. You could even move to a quiet, calm room away from the main hustle and bustle of the house.
• Introduce white noise: The womb was not silent. A consistent, low-rumbling sound can be very soothing. A sound machine with a deep "brown noise" or a shushing sound can help block out other sudden household noises.

When your baby is overwhelmed, pulling back on stimulation is often the best thing you can do. Dim lights, quiet sounds, and gentle motion can transform a chaotic space into a calm one, helping your baby's immature nervous system find its rhythm again.

Once you have created a calmer space, you can add layers of comfort that tap right into your baby’s need for security and rhythm.

Master Rhythmic Motion and Secure Swaddling

Movement is a language your baby understands instinctively. Gentle, repetitive motion is one of the most reliable ways to soothe a fussy baby during the newborn witching hour.

• Babywearing: Wearing your baby in a soft sling or carrier keeps them snug against your body. They feel your warmth, hear your heartbeat, and are gently rocked by your movements. It often works wonders.
• Rocking and swaying: A gentle rock in a chair or a rhythmic sway while you stand can be incredibly effective. The predictability of the motion makes it so calming.
• Swaddling: A snug swaddle gives that feeling of being held securely, just like in the womb. It also helps stop their startle reflex from waking them or adding to their distress. Just make sure the swaddle is firm but still allows for healthy hip movement.

Manage Feeding and Tummy Discomfort

Cluster feeding and gas are common culprits during the witching hour. Getting on top of these can make a huge difference.

If your baby is cluster feeding, try to settle into a comfortable spot with everything you need close by. It is a completely normal and temporary phase that helps boost your milk supply for the days ahead.

For gas and discomfort, a few simple techniques can bring relief. Make sure you burp your baby well during and after feeds. Gentle tummy massage or bicycling their legs can also help release trapped wind, making it easier for them to finally settle down.

Building a Calming Evening Routine

When you are navigating the newborn witching hour, predictability is your best friend. A consistent evening routine is like a gentle whisper to your baby’s developing brain, letting them know the busy day is winding down and it is time for rest.

This is not about a rigid, clock-watching schedule. It is about creating a sequence of calming moments that happen in the same order each evening. These predictable steps can help dial down the intensity of those fussy spells and bring a welcome sense of order to what can feel like chaos.

Let's break it down. The goal is to build a peaceful rhythm you can adapt to your baby’s cues, because consistency always wins over perfection.

Designing Your Soothing Sequence

Your routine should centre on quiet activities that lower stimulation and encourage relaxation. A great way to start is by “putting the house to sleep” about an hour before you would like your baby to be asleep. This just means dimming the lights, turning off the television, and softening your voices.

Here’s a simple, flexible routine you can make your own:

1. A Warm, Calming Bath: The warm water can be incredibly soothing for a fussy baby. Keep it brief and gentle, using slow movements and a soft voice. It’s the perfect way to transition from active daytime to quiet evening.

2. Gentle Baby Massage: After the bath, a gentle massage with a baby-safe lotion can help relax their tense little muscles. Use long, slow strokes on their legs, arms, and back. This loving touch is a powerful way to connect and offer comfort.

3. Quiet Feed in a Dim Room: For the last feed of the evening, move to a dimly lit room. This minimises distractions, helping your baby focus on feeding and drift off feeling full and sleepy. This peaceful environment is a key part of the wind-down process.

A consistent routine does more than just calm your baby in the moment. Over time, it helps set their developing internal clock, teaching them the difference between the activity of day and the quiet of night.

Setting up a dedicated calm-down corner can make this routine even more effective. Creating a peaceful space is one of many great newborn nursery ideas that will support your efforts to tame the witching hour.

Key Elements for a Peaceful Atmosphere

The environment you create is just as important as the activities themselves. Your baby is incredibly attuned to their surroundings, so making a few small changes can have a huge impact on their mood during that tricky time of day.

Focus on Sensory Calm:

• Sound: A white noise machine with a deep, rumbling sound can be a game-changer. It helps block out sudden household noises and mimics the constant, comforting sounds of the womb.
• Sight: Stick to a dim, warm lamp. Bright overhead lights are stimulating and can make it much harder for an overtired baby to settle.
• Smell: Avoid using strong perfumes or scented products in the evening. A simple, familiar scent like their baby lotion is all that’s needed.

Remember, this routine is for you, too. Taking these slow, intentional steps each evening can help you feel more in control and connected to your baby during a challenging phase. It transforms the witching hour from something to endure into a time for quiet connection.

Knowing When to Seek Professional Advice

While the newborn witching hour is a completely normal developmental phase, it is essential to trust your parental instincts. You know your baby best.

If you ever feel like the evening fussiness is more than just typical witching hour behaviour, it is always best to seek professional advice for peace of mind. Most of the time, this fussy period is harmless, but sometimes it can mask an underlying issue that needs attention. Acting on that gut feeling that something is not quite right is a crucial part of parenting.

Red Flags to Watch For

Let's break down some specific signs that mean you should contact your GP, paediatrician, or child health nurse. These symptoms go beyond the usual challenges of the witching hour and definitely warrant a professional opinion.

Keep an eye out for these indicators:

• Signs of Illness: A fever is a clear reason to call a doctor. Other signs include lethargy, difficulty waking, or a cry that sounds unusually high-pitched or pained.
• Feeding and Digestion Issues: Forceful or projectile vomiting is different from normal spit-up. Also, be mindful of a sudden refusal to feed or signs of significant discomfort during or after feeding.
• Dehydration Concerns: Pay attention to your baby’s nappies. A significant decrease in the number of wet nappies is a key sign of dehydration and needs to be addressed quickly.
• No Calm Periods: While the witching hour is intense, most babies have content periods at other times of the day. If your baby seems uncomfortable or distressed around the clock, it could point to an underlying issue like reflux or an allergy.

Trusting your intuition is your most powerful tool. If you feel something is wrong, you are your baby's best advocate. It is always better to get checked and be reassured than to worry alone at home.

Navigating these intense evenings can be draining for the whole family. If the evening fussiness is severely impacting your sleep and wellbeing, a professional new parent's guide to night nurses for newborns might offer practical solutions for managing challenging nights. Remember, seeking support for yourself is just as important as caring for your baby.

Your Questions About the Witching Hour Answered

Let's walk through some of the most common questions parents have about this tricky evening phase. Having clear answers can give you the confidence you need to get through it calmly and know you are doing a great job.

Does Every Baby Experience This?

Not every single baby will have a distinct, clockwork witching hour. While it is incredibly common, some newborns are just naturally more settled in the evenings. If that is your baby, count yourself lucky! But know that most parents will experience it to some degree.

This phase is a completely normal part of their development, not a sign that you are doing anything wrong.

How Can Partners Support Each Other?

Teamwork is everything. When one parent is feeling touched-out and overwhelmed, the other can step in. It helps to have a "tap-out" system where you can hand the baby over and just take five minutes to breathe and reset.

A little preparation goes a long way, too. Making sure you have everything you need on hand before the fussiness kicks in can be a game-changer. You can check out our guide on nappy bag essentials for new mums to get your supplies sorted.

Can a Pacifier Help Settle My Baby?

Yes, a pacifier can be a fantastic tool for calming your little one. Many newborns have a really strong urge to suck for comfort, even when they are not hungry. This is called non-nutritive sucking, and it can be incredibly soothing for a baby who is feeling overstimulated.

You cannot spoil a newborn. Responding to your baby's cries for comfort with cuddles, feeding, and soothing is exactly what they need. This builds a strong sense of security and trust, which is vital for their emotional development.

Getting through the witching hour often means managing intense feelings for both you and your baby. Understanding how to help little ones with their big emotions is a valuable skill. If you are interested in learning more, you can find helpful resources on children's emotions that offer broader insights.

---

At Wallaby Collective, we believe in creating calm, beautiful spaces for your family. Our soft linen play mats provide the perfect, comfortable spot for quiet time and connection, helping you build a peaceful evening routine to soothe your little one. Discover our collection of stylish, easy-care play mats.